Evaluate and discuss whether Black and Beale conducted themselves in accordance with auditing standards.


Winston Black was an audit partner in the firm of Henson, Davis & Company. He was in the process of reviewing the audit files for the audit of a new client, McMullan Resources. McMullan was in the business of heavy construction. Black was conducting his first review after the audit was substantially complete. Normally, he would have done an initial review during the planning phase as required by his firm’s policies; however, he had been overwhelmed by an emergency with his largest and most important client. He rationalized not reviewing audit planning information because (1) the audit was being overseen by Sarah Beale, a manager in whom he had confidence, and (2) he could “recover” from any problems during his end-of-audit review.

Now Black found that he was confronted with a couple of problems. First, he found that the firm may have accepted McMullan without complying with its new-client acceptance procedures. McMullan came to Henson, Davis & Company on a recommendation from a friend of Black’s. Black got “credit” for the new business, which was important to him because it would affect his compensation from the firm. Because Black was busy, he told Beale to conduct a new-client acceptance review and let him know if there were any problems. He never heard from Beale and assumed everything was okay. In reviewing Beale’s preaudit planning documentation, he saw a check mark in the box “Contact prior auditors” but found no details indicating what was done. When he asked Beale about this,

she responded with the following:

“I called Gardner Smith [the responsible partner with McMullan’s prior audit firm] and left a voicemail message for him. He never returned my call. I talked to Ted McMullan about the change, and he told me that he informed Gardner about the change and that Gardner said, ‘Fine, I’ll help in any way I can.’ Ted said Gardner sent over copies of analyses of fixed assets and equity accounts, which Ted gave to me. I asked Ted why they replaced Gardner’s firm, and he told me it was over the tax contingency issue and the size of their fee. Other than that, Ted said the relationship was fine.”
The tax contingency issue that Beale referred to was a situation in which McMullan had entered into litigation with a bank from which it had received a loan. The result of the litigation was that the bank forgave several hundred thousand dollars in debt. This was a windfall to McMullan, and they recorded it as a gain, taking the position that it was nontax- able. The prior auditors disputed this position and insisted that a contingent tax liability existed that required disclosure. This upset McMullan, but the company agreed in order to receive an unmodified opinion. Before hiring Henson, Davis & Company as their new auditors, McMullan requested that the firm review the situation. Henson, Davis & Company believed the contingency was remote and agreed to the elimination of the disclosure.
The second problem involved a long-term contract with a customer in Montreal. Under accounting standards, McMullan was required to recognize income on this contract using the percentage-of-completion method. The contract was partially completed as of year end and had a material effect on the financial statements. When Black went to review the copy of the contract in the audit files, he found three things. First, there was a contract summary that set out its major features. Second, there was a copy of the contract written in French. Third, there was a signed confirmation confirming the terms and status of the contract. The space requesting information about any contract disputes was left blank, indicating no such problems. Black’s concern about the contract was that to recognize income in accordance with accounting standards, the contract had to be enforceable. Often, contracts contain a cancellation clause that might mitigate enforceability. Because he was not able to read

See also  Determine the cost of goods sold for March. Round your answer to the nearest dollar.

French, Black couldn’t tell whether the contract contained such a clause. When he asked Beale about this, she responded that she had asked the company’s vice president for the Canadian division about the contract and he told her that it was their standard contract. The company’s standard contract did have a cancellation clause in it, but it required mutual agreement and could not be cancelled unilaterally by the buyer.

a. Evaluate and discuss whether Henson, Davis & Company complied with auditing standards in their acceptance of McMullan Resources as a new client. What can they do at this point in the engagement to resolve deficiencies if they exist?

b. Evaluate and discuss whether sufficient audit work has been done with regard to McMullan’s Montreal contract. If not, what more should be done?

c. Evaluate and discuss whether Black and Beale conducted themselves in accordance with auditing standards.

Custompaper.help is an academic writing platform that provides students and professionals with quality services to ease their assignment challenges. With a wide range of services, the platform has become one of the leading academic writing service providers in the market due to its reliability and affordability. Below, we shall discuss some of the services which Custompaper.help provides:

See also  Identify the consequences of having dissatisfied employees and describe ways of applying the four theories of job satisfaction and how you would use them to boost job satisfaction.

Essay Writing Service
The essay writing service provides customers with quality essays on any subject or topic they requested within a given deadline. The writers at custompaper are experts in their respective fields, and they ensure customer satisfaction by producing original content with thorough research involved backed up with strong evidence from reliable sources available online or offline. All essays come with free plagiarism reports as well as revisions if needed so that customers can trust that they are getting high-quality work for their money’s worth.

Research Paper Writing Service
This is another popular service offered by custom paper help wherein customers are assisted in conducting research papers according to their needs and requirements within specified deadlines. Writers at custom paper help have vast knowledge about various topics belonging to different disciplines such as Management, Arts & Humanities, History etc., allowing them to craft impeccable research papers every time regardless of the complexity or urgency level requested by customers. Additionally, all our research papers come along with proper citation formats which ensures customer’s safety when it comes to plagiarism issues while also helping them save time on formatting procedures thus improving overall efficiency even further!

Dissertation Writing Service
CustomPaperHelp also offers dissertation writing assistance for those who need it most – students preparing for graduation or professionals wanting to further refine their skills through higher education levels such as Master/PhD degrees etc, Our team of writers consists of experienced individuals having Master’s/PhD degrees themselves so you can rest assured that your dissertation will be handled expertly from the start till the end! Furthermore, we offer unlimited revisions until your complete satisfaction is achieved, along with regular checkups being done throughout the process just so everything goes according to course without any hiccups!

See also  Write a 2-3 page paper reflecting on your learning in Communication & Collaboration II: Teamwork.

Editing And Proofreading Services
If you already have written an essay but want professional feedback before submitting it, then CustomPaperHelp also offers editing & proofreading services which helps in identifying & rectifying errors present in assignments like grammar mistakes, spelling mistakes, punctuation problems etc., thereby ensuring top-notch quality work, before submission takes place! We understand how important accuracy & consistency are when it comes to grading systems used at universities nowadays, so taking extra care during this phase becomes absolutely essential if good grades are desired afterward!

Coursework Help
For those who find coursework difficult due to complications of being quite technical in nature; CustomPaperHelp extends its support here too, by providing quality solutions every single time – starting from understanding concepts properly up until composing flawless answers following university guidelines closely enough making sure no loopholes remain whatsoever! Whether it’s related math problem-solving algorithms or lengthy home assignments – our expert panel has got you covered from head-to-toe leaving no stone unturned during this very crucial stage since final grades depend largely upon the success rate achieved here successfully!

Assignment Help
Assignments form an integral part of getting better scores & ultimately, a degree itself (in case pursuing a masters/PhD) – something only possible if precision is made a priority right away; otherwise, chances of failure increase exponentially over a time period detrimentally affecting performance evaluation systems later down road drastically hence stressing timely importance completion prior commencement other operations associated same project altogether consistently meeting high standards expected each situation respectively! Here too, CustomPaperHelp presents comprehensive solution package exceeding expectations beyond point offering optimal values therein ensuring maximum satisfaction reached under circumstances prevailing accordingly without fail…proving once more why people trust us implicitly without second thought whatsoever!!

Calculate your paper price
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Why Choose Us

Quality Papers

We value our clients. For this reason, we ensure that each paper is written carefully as per the instructions provided by the client. Our editing team also checks all the papers to ensure that they have been completed as per the expectations.

Professional Academic Writers

Over the years, our Acme Homework has managed to secure the most qualified, reliable and experienced team of writers. The company has also ensured continued training and development of the team members to ensure that it keep up with the rising Academic Trends.

Affordable Prices

Our prices are fairly priced in such a way that ensures affordability. Additionally, you can get a free price quotation by clicking on the "Place Order" button.

On-Time delivery

We pay strict attention on deadlines. For this reason, we ensure that all papers are submitted earlier, even before the deadline indicated by the customer. For this reason, the client can go through the work and review everything.

100% Originality

At Custom Paper Help, all papers are plagiarism-free as they are written from scratch. We have taken strict measures to ensure that there is no similarity on all papers and that citations are included as per the standards set.

Customer Support 24/7

Our support team is readily available to provide any guidance/help on our platform at any time of the day/night. Feel free to contact us via the Chat window or support email: support@acmehomework.com.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Services

Custom Paper Help has stood as the world’s leading custom essay writing services providers. Once you enter all the details in the order form under the place order button, the rest is up to us.


Essay Writing Services

At Custom Paper Help, we prioritize on all aspects that bring about a good grade such as impeccable grammar, proper structure, zero-plagiarism and conformance to guidelines. Our experienced team of writers will help you completed your essays and other assignments.


Admission and Business Papers

Be assured that you’ll definitely get accepted to the Master’s level program at any university once you enter all the details in the order form. We won’t leave you here; we will also help you secure a good position in your aspired workplace by creating an outstanding resume or portfolio once you place an order.


Editing and Proofreading

Our skilled editing and writing team will help you restructure you paper, paraphrase, correct grammar and replace plagiarized sections on your paper just on time. The service is geared toward eliminating any mistakes and rather enhancing better quality.


Technical papers

We have writers in almost all fields including the most technical fields. You don’t have to worry about the complexity of your paper. Simply enter as much details as possible in the place order section.