Instructions
- For this assignment you are going to identify a complex healthcare ethical dilemma facing the professional nurse in our multi-dimensional healthcare environment.
- This ethical dilemma can be one that you have observed in your current practice setting or one that you have observed in the literature.
- Once you have identified/selected the complex healthcare ethical dilemma you will conduct an in-depth exploration of the literature about the dilemma you have identified/selected.
- You will need to consider and identify Stakeholders relevant to the identified complex healthcare ethical dilemma so that you can explore their individual perspectives in your presentation.
Presentation Requirements:
Your presentation needs to include the following:
- Introduction: (1-2 slides)
- Define the meaning of healthcare ethics and its importance in the healthcare field.
- Ethical Dilemma Overview: (1-2 slides)
- Provide a brief overview of the complex healthcare ethical dilemma you have identified/selected for the purposes of the assignment.
- Ethical Problem Analysis: (1-3 slides)
- Discuss the ethical principles operational in the complex healthcare ethical dilemma you have identified/selected.
- Stakeholders: (1-3 slides)
- Identify the stakeholders relevant to the identified complex healthcare ethical dilemma and describe how values and perspectives of the stakeholders are impacted by the dilemma.
- Conclusion: (1 slide)
- Summarize the main points discussed in the presentation.
π© Introduction (1β2 slides)
Slide 1: What Are Healthcare Ethics?
-
Healthcare ethics is the study and application of moral principles and values in clinical settings.
-
It guides decision-making to ensure patient welfare, fairness, and professional integrity.
-
Key ethical principles: autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice.
Slide 2: Importance in Healthcare
-
Provides a framework to resolve complex dilemmas.
-
Protects patient rights and promotes trust.
-
Ensures professional accountability and legal compliance.
π¦ Ethical Dilemma Overview (1β2 slides)
Slide 3: Description of the Dilemma
-
End-of-life decision-making often involves withdrawing or withholding life-sustaining treatment (e.g., mechanical ventilation).
-
Nurses face conflicting responsibilities: respecting patient/family wishes vs. prolonging life.
Slide 4: Why Itβs Complex
-
Involves emotional, cultural, religious, legal, and clinical factors.
-
Unclear prognosis and family disagreements often complicate decisions.
-
Nurses must balance compassion with professional ethics.
π¨ Ethical Problem Analysis (1β3 slides)
Slide 5: Ethical Principles Involved
-
Autonomy: Respecting patientβs right to make their own end-of-life decisions.
-
Beneficence: Acting in the best interest of the patient.
-
Nonmaleficence: Avoiding unnecessary suffering or harm.
-
Justice: Fair allocation of resources and consistent application of policies.
Slide 6: Ethical Tensions
-
Disagreements between healthcare team and family on prognosis.
-
Emotional burden on nurses who provide ongoing care.
-
Conflicts between personal beliefs and professional responsibilities.
π§ Stakeholders (1β3 slides)
Slide 7: Identifying Stakeholders
Slide 8: Stakeholder Perspectives
-
Patient: May want comfort-focused care rather than aggressive treatment.
-
Family: May experience guilt, grief, or hope for recovery, influencing their decisions.
-
Nurses: Experience moral distress and emotional fatigue while advocating for patient wishes.
-
Physicians: Must balance medical evidence, ethics, and legal considerations.
-
Ethics committee/legal team: Ensure compliance with laws and hospital policies.
π© Conclusion (1 slide)
Slide 9: Summary
-
Ethical dilemmas like end-of-life decisions require careful balancing of ethical principles and stakeholder values.
-
Nurses play a vital role in advocacy, communication, and ethical decision-making.
-
Collaboration, ethical frameworks, and institutional policies support ethical nursing practice.
π Suggested References (APA)
-
American Nurses Association. (2015). Code of ethics for nurses with interpretive statements. ANA.
-
Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
-
Schuster, D. L., & Nykamp, D. (2020). Ethical decision-making in end-of-life care. Critical Care Nurse, 40(2), 22β32.
-
National Institute on Aging. (2021). End-of-life care. https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/end-of-life